Sell Silver Coins

Would you like to sell silver coins in Sarasota, or in the surrounding area of Florida? The Honest Gold Guy buys silver coins, commemorative sets, U.S. Silver Eagles, Canadian Silver Maple Leaf coins, silver jewelry, silver flatware, gold jewelry, scrap gold, fractional gold coins,and more.

If you have U.S. coins, Canadian coins, Australian coins, U.S. territory coins, or coins that you just can’t identify, bring them in to the Honest Gold Guy of Sarasota. While you are at it bring in you broken or unwanted silver and gold, and carry a an extra paycheck.

What kind of silver coins do we buy?

Just about any circulated or uncirculated pre-1965 coins, such as 90% silver dimes, quarters, half dollars, and silver dollars. The only nickels that are silver are the war nickels dated 1942 to 1945. They contain 35% silver.

We also buy .999 silver rounds, casino tokens, silver bars, American Silver Eagles, (these are .999 silver) Canadian Maple Leaf coins, and silver commemorative coins of all types.

Value of Silver Coins

The value of silver coins is determined by three things.

All silver coins have value based on their silver content and weight. This value fluctuates daily, depending on that day’s silver spot price. Some silver coins have greater value due to their rarity, and even more value if they are in really good, or uncirculated condition.

Free Appraisals

I usually provide a free appraisal of your silver coins, or coin collections. If you are unsure, or curious about the value of your collection of silver coins, silver bullion, or gold coins please bring them in for a free appraisal.

What We Pay For Silver Coins

For common silver coins we pay a high percentage of the daily spot price. The daily spot is set by the New York Commodity Exchange trading markets. As a dealer we set our prices daily, and usually pay a rate below, or up to the spot market. This price can be higher for a large cache of coins. Some of my customers have told me that I paid them twice the closest quote they had from a competitor.


As a coin dealer and a gold and silver buyer, we have one of two things we do with your silver coins. usually we sell these coins to coin collectors, other dealers, or silver investors.

What We Sell Silver Coins For

We sell silver coins at retail for a small percentage above spot. These prices can go down based on the size of the purchase.

if you need to sell old silver coins in the Sarasota, FL. area, please call me at 941-915-2978. My store is easy to find. I am at the corner of Webber Street and Beneva Rd., right behind the Goodwill Donation center, and next door to West Coast Accounting. The actual address is 3575 Webber St., Suite 103, Sarasota, FL. 34239.

I sell Silver Locally, Too

Are you a silver stacker? Hey, I buy a lot of silver coins and prefer to sell them locally, when possible. Usually, my prices are around 4% to 10% over spot. Yes, I do have to make a profit. Buying silver coins locally will save you postage. You will not have to worry about being ripped off by an out of state seller. I buy, and sell coins locally.

Please call 941-915-2978 to make an appointment.

I currently serve these local markets: Sarasota, Osprey, Nokomis, Venice, Lakewood ranch, University Park, Bradenton, Palmetto, Gulfport, Siesta Key, Longboat Key, St. Petersburg, Wauchula, Ellenton, and many other rural Tampa Bay Florida locations.

The Honest Gold Guy of Sarasota
3575 Webber Street, Suite 103
Sarasota, FL 34239
Ph 941-915-2978

My office is at the intersection of Webber Street, and Beneva Road. I’m right behind the Goodwill Donation Center, and next door to West Coast Accounting.
Page Updated 12/18/2012
Leave Sell Silver Coins & Return to Site Map